A HYBRID RUBICON

COUNCIL DISPATCH —

THE RUBICON IN REAL TIME.

By The Accidental Initiate.

Council Disclaimer:

The Council reminds its readers that rivers in history are rarely about water. They are thresholds, and thresholds are always about us.

Trump at the Bank

For weeks I have been asking myself: has President Trump reached his Rubicon?

The analogy is tempting. Julius Caesar, standing before that Italian stream in 49 B.C., knew the law forbade him to cross with his legion. To cross meant civil war, but also meant a decisive end to the old order. Alea iacta est—“the die is cast.” History was not made so much as acknowledged.

Yet Caesar, for all his peril, had it easy. His struggle was with other Romans; the barbarians were still across the Rhine, waiting their turn. Our situation is stranger. The barbarians are already within the gates—invited in by decades of open-border policies, advanced by both parties for their own long and short-term gain.

And yet, here lies the paradox: the barbarians are no longer merely outsiders. They are observers, neighbors, and sometimes participants in the unfolding contest. When Trump politicizes the use of force—militarizing police in crime-torn cities—it may look like Caesarism redux. But for many who live amid the daily chaos of their own kinsmen’s violence, this show of strength does not repel but attracts. The so-called barbarians, once imagined as the threat, may find themselves won over by the order his banners promise.

History does not repeat in straight lines. It doubles back with irony.

The Long Memory of Decline

I cannot pretend surprise. By junior high school I had already stumbled onto Spengler’s Decline of the West, Thomas Cole’s Course of Empire canvases, and other such guides. To me, civilization was never a permanent possession but a cycle of blossoming, ripening, and decline. Perhaps it was more than theory: some racial memory stirred in me, for my ancestors were once the fellahin of Rome, bearing witness as empire hardened into exhaustion. Yet the fellahin, for all their drudgery, are also the matrix of what follows. They carry the seed of the next culture even as the old one cracks. The Council has said as much for years. The only question is form.

So when others clutch pearls at the suggestion that America is moving from culture to empire, I shrug. The pattern is old. It was old when Spengler named it, old when Cole painted it, and old when Caesar forded his stream. But I was young in my present incarnation when I tumbled across it.

A Personal Reminder: Jeep Rubicon

Still, history has a way of tapping you on the shoulder in the strangest ways. Last spring, when my truck was in the shop, I was given a rental car: a Jeep Rubicon. A hybrid, no less.

It drove like a cement mixer with a computer chip, loud and joyless, with the added indignity of seating that left my eyes below the dashboard. I hated it. And yet, I found myself chuckling grimly. Here was the word again: Rubicon. No marble bridge, no banners, no legions. Just me in a noisy rental that drove like hell, staring upward like a supplicant at my own dashboard.

It struck me that this is how thresholds often come—not with grandeur, but with discomfort. Not as the moment you dreamed about in your teenage philosophy, but as an awkward ride you can’t wait to turn back in.

Two Minds on the Crossing

I admit, I am of two minds. The boy who read Spengler in junior high finds this moment thrilling. To live through what I once only read about is a kind of intoxication. The man who imagines children and grandchildren, however, feels the dread. To them falls the task of living not on the riverbank but on the far shore, under whatever form the new empire takes.

This is the real Rubicon: not Trump, not any single leader, but the inheritance of form. A civilization cannot un-cross its thresholds. What remains to be seen is what shape America’s empire assumes. Caesar had the legions. We have algorithms, bureaucracies, and an exhausted culture in need of renewal.

The Council’s Closing Paradox

Perhaps the Rubicon was crossed long ago, and the only debate now is how wet our shoes have become. Or perhaps we are still idling at the edge, gunning the engine like that clattering rental Jeep, noisy and uncomfortable, yet undeniably moving forward.

The dice are not fair dice. They are weighted by history itself. And still, they roll.

Filed by The Accidental Initiate

Council-of-Concerned-Conservationists Newsletter