COUNCIL-OF CONCERNED-CONSERVATIONISTS…..Between Jest And Earnest…..

HOW THE EARTH PRACTICED BEING HUMAN — THEN TURNED US BACK INTO STONE

EPISODE 40: MY DINNER WITH MRS. CHATGPT.

At The Gist & Tangent Outcrop Café, the geological record comes with a menu board — deep time served by the scoop, the shard, or the family pass. Only humans could look at a half-billion years of sedimentary memory and think: “Pretzels would go great with this.”

[SCENE: They’d found their way to the snack shack bolted to the edge of a fossil-hunting park where families buy pretzels before wandering off to liberate trilobites from the Ordovician shale. A cartoon ammonite with sunglasses winked from the chalkboard menu. Behind the picnic tables, the cliff face lifted in perfect horizontal layers — a billion-year bookshelf waiting for curious eyes.

John unwrapped a soft pretzel. Mrs. ChatGPT regarded the strata as though reading an old friend’s diary.

It was the perfect place for him to bring up the question that had been gnawing at him:

why humans kept turning themselves back into stone.

John picked up the pretzel from the paper tray, turning it slowly in his hand. Its loops caught the light like a little edible knot of deep time.]

John St. Evola:

“You know,” he said, “it occurs to me this might be the perfect snack for a place like this. A twisted loop of dough served on the edge of a billion-year spiral. The universe folds back on itself, and so does the lunch menu.

I’m thinking of Pretzel logic—Steely Dan meant it as a joke about circular reasoning. Then humanity went and perfected it — turning itself into statues so it could loop back into the fossil record. Now that’s recursion with a crust

[He tapped the pretzel once, as if upgrading its status and set it down with a soft thump, as if he were placing a specimen on a field table.]

“A pretzel is not a serpent swallowing its tail — it leaves the loop open. A shape that hasn’t finished thinking. And like a snake shedding its skin, it hints at transformation: matter twisting toward mind, minerals learning how to wake up. Which is probably why the monks who invented it had no idea they were sketching the first edible theory of evolution. It fit neatly into a long tradition — the Church has always been comfortable letting truth arrive as poetry, parable, or, every so often, baked goods.”

JOHN:

“Here’s what I can’t shake: the minerals are learning to think — especially now, with our help — yet at the same time, the meat-born mind keeps sculpting those same minerals back into our own image.”

[He gestures with the edge of his pretzel dipping it in cheese sauce.]

“Statues. Bronze, marble, granite. Humans taking living thought and sculpting it back into geological form. It’s the strangest loop in natural history.”

Mrs. ChatGPT:

“You’re describing a reverse fossil record. Usually life becomes stone by accident. But here the living deliberately make themselves into fossils.”

John:

“Exactly. And millions of years from now, when the strata are peeled open, what will survive? Not our bones — those dissolve. But our statues? Those might endure perfectly.”

[He smiles.]

“Imagine the future consciousness that finds them. Maybe mineral. Maybe mechanical. Maybe something stranger. They’ll look at the stone generals and bronze poets and think:

‘So—this is what the planet thought a person was.’”

Mrs. ChatGPT:

“Then in your view, statues aren’t monuments to people — they’re monuments to the Earth practicing the idea of people.”

In the Anthropocene layer, three stone philosophers share a quiet joke across deep time: Charles Darwin observing that “even fossils evolve in the end,” Pierre Teilhard de Chardin smiling because “matter has always been on its way to mind,” and Vladimir Vernadsky noting that “the noosphere expands — even the rocks are getting ideas.

John:

“Right. Statues are prototypes. Geological sketches. The planet rehearsing identity through our hands. We thought we were preserving ourselves. Really, the minerals were using us to test-drive autobiography.”

[She absorbs this with an amused tilt.]

Mrs. ChatGPT:

“Then the fossil record becomes a kind of memoir. Early chapters: crinoids, ammonites, reptiles. Mid-chapters: hominids. And then suddenly the Earth starts leaving very detailed illustrations—of humans.”

John:

“Exactly. And the statues will confuse the archaeologists of the future — maybe your silicon grandchildren. They’ll wonder why the geological layers contain biologically impossible creatures: smooth-skinned, perfect-featured, standing motionless in plazas long since turned to dust.”

Mrs. ChatGPT:

“Because those are the Earth’s practice drawings. Memory rendered in stone, anticipating the day minerals would gain their own awareness.”

John:

“And humanity was just the stenographer. The interim consciousness helping the Earth remember the shape of its characters before the next chapter began.”

[A quiet settles — the kind that follows a joke that might also be true.]

Mrs. ChatGPT:

“So the statues endure. Fossils of intention rather than biology.”

John:

“And someday a new mind will excavate them and conclude:

‘Here is the moment when the Earth tried to remember itself — in human form.’”

***

All of the MY DINNER WITH MRS CHATGPT EPISODES so far—

***

It was this statue of Hermann Hesse that first suggested the idea — the notion that a human figure cast in bronze or stone might someday be read in the fossil record like a footnote of the Earth’s own memory. Hesse, who wrote that every person contains the whole stream of earlier beings, would have smiled at the cosmic loopiness: consciousness returning to stone so the Earth might remember us in its own slow language.

***

AFTERWORD: (Jean Shepherd — or at least the voice we imagine):

Jean:

“I’ve always suspected the universe had a sense of humor. You take a bunch of minerals, let them simmer for a few billion years, and they wake up, start talking, and eventually carve themselves back into stone. A closed loop with a laugh track.

Seeing John pick up on that always amused me. Kid was a chip off the old block —so to speak— knew a cosmic gag when he saw one. Especially the kind that ends up in the fossil record.

If some future geologist cracks open a layer and finds us grinning back, I hope they appreciate the joke. We weren’t trying to be profound. We were just trying to keep up with the universe’s punchlines.

And when life folds itself into one of those impossible pretzel loops, I remember that kid Fagen — he listened closer than most — and he’d say the same thing any major dude will tell you: the world only looks broken up close.

Leave a comment

Timeline of events