—Dr. Faye is a Fellow at The Council’s Institute for Theoretical Studies (TIfTS)
—Filed under: Mental Hygiene Directives
OPENING MEMORANDUM
There exists a lesser-known cognitive disturbance, adjacent to but inverse of déjà vu, in which the patient encounters a recurring phenomenon and experiences it as entirely unprecedented.
This condition is termed Jamais Vu—or, in lay terminology, the perpetual first time.
CASE STUDY: VANCE GUNCZARUS
***
TRANSCRIPT OF CONSULTATION
Recorded for archival purposes; soundtrack applied as both diagnostic instrument and symptomatic expression.
DR. FAYE:
State your concern.
VANCE:
Something’s off.
Feels like everything keeps happening for the first time.
“Feels Like the First Time” — courtesy of Foreigner. Interpretation provided by Vance Gunczarus
***
DR. FAYE:
Everything feels like the first time?
VANCE:
Big things. Serious things. Situations where people say, “this is unprecedented.”
And I agree. Every time.
DR. FAYE:
And you experience no sense of familiarity?
VANCE:
None.
If anything, I feel like people are overcomplicating it by bringing up the past.
DR. FAYE (noting):
Aversion to precedent. Mark that.
DR. FAYE:
Let us proceed.
I will present a scenario. You will respond naturally.
[She slides forward a visual document.]
DIAGNOSTIC EXHIBIT A
Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young, Dallas Taylor, and Greg Reeves, Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young, Dallas Taylor, and Greg Reeves, etc., ad infinitum.
***
DR. FAYE:
Describe what you see.
VANCE (leans in):
Two completely different situations.
DR. FAYE:
Continue.
VANCE:
Left—some kind of old storage situation. Unclear. Right—modern, serious, high-tech threat. Not the same at all.
DR. FAYE:
You detect no structural similarity?
VANCE:
No, ma’am. Different time. Different place. Different facts.
DR. FAYE:
Different conclusions?
VANCE (after a beat):
No.
Same conclusion.
DR. FAYE (writing):
Remarkable.
Hello In There. Vance, you home?
***
CLINICAL INTERPRETATION
The patient demonstrates classic symptoms of Jamais Vu.
Recurrent frameworks are perceived as isolated events. Continuity is severed at the level of recognition, while outcomes remain eerily consistent.
DR. FAYE (aloud, to patient):
Tell me—when you hear the phrase “we have all been here before,” what do you feel?
VANCE:
Confused.
Because we haven’t.
DR. FAYE:
Even when presented with evidence?
VANCE:
Especially then.
DR. FAYE (softly):
Yes. . . that aligns.
ADVANCED SYMPTOMS
In prolonged cases, the patient develops resistance not merely to memory, but to pattern recognition itself.
Each recurrence is metabolized as novelty.
Each warning is heard as announcement.
DR. FAYE:
Do you believe you are learning from events?
VANCE:
Absolutely.
DR. FAYE:
What have you learned?
VANCE (confident):
That this time is different.
DR. FAYE (closing her notebook):
Of course.
***
PROGNOSIS
Without intervention, the patient will continue to encounter identical conditions under the persistent impression of originality.
Consent will be granted repeatedly under the guise of discovery.
RECOMMENDED TREATMENT
Controlled exposure to archival material Repetition of unchanged cultural artifacts (music, recordings, transcripts) Gradual restoration of temporal continuity.
VANCE:
You’re telling me I need to study old material to understand what’s happening now?
DR. FAYE:
No. I am telling you it is the old material.
VANCE (after a long pause): That doesn’t feel right.
DR. FAYE:
No. It wouldn’t.
FINAL NOTE (FOR THE RECORD)
The tragedy of déjà vu is recognition without control.
The tragedy of jamais vu is repetition without recognition.
MENTAL HYGIENE DIRECTIVE #27
If everything feels new, consult the archive before proceeding.
***
More from Dr. Faye C. Schüß (Pronounced Schuess for our English readers.)
COUNCIL-OF CONCERNED-CONSERVATIONISTS…..Between Jest And Earnest….. 
Leave a comment